Year in Review: 2009

In 2009, I was attending college full-time, living on my own just off campus. I wanted to get into comics, but I didn't have enough money, so I mostly just started collecting the major trade paperbacks. Or just reading them in the library. In fact, in a couple of years, I would read Legion of 3 Worlds for the first time in my university's library. I didn't understand it, but I was enthralled by it.

Although 2008 was a huge year for superhero films, 2009 was incredibly quiet. Almost like the calm before the storm. Marvel's only offering was X-Men Origins: Wolverine and DC's sole venture was Watchmen. I think the kindest thing to say about both those movies was that they each had mixed reviews. Elsewhere, the box office was absolutely dominated by Avatar, which pulled in $2.7 billion. And 10 years later, we're still waiting on that promised sequel. But just to show how far ahead Avatar was over everything else, the second-highest grossing film of the year, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, earned only $934 million. Despite Avatar's financial dominance, it was The Hurt Locker that came away with the Oscars for Best Picture, Best Director and Best Original Screenplay.

And how did our little boy Bart do in 2009? Quite well, actually, considering he was literally brought back to life! Of course, it was kind of strange how he died as a 20-year-old but came back as a 16-year-old, but hey, nobody really liked Bart as the Flash anyway, right? And the important thing is Bart is back! (Even if he has to be Kid Flash again.) Bart was brought back during Legion of 3 Worlds, and before that miniseries ended, he was thrown into Flash: Rebirth. But before that ended, Bart was thrown into another, even larger event, Blackest Night. So it was a pretty wild, busy year for Bart, that unfortunately was hampered by some continuity issues. I guess it's also worth mentioning that in 2009, Impulse also made his smallest, least-memorable cameo on the Smallville TV show.

Best Issue: Final Crisis: Legions of 3 Worlds #4

Bart technically came back to life in the third issue of this miniseries, but that was only on the last page. In issue #4, he was fully back, immediately cracking jokes, reuniting with his cousin, XS, and, most importantly, terrorizing Superboy-Prime. Bart never could actually defeat Prime by himself, but he can get under Prime's skin like no one else. It was a pure delight watching Bart help turn the tide of the battle against one of the most powerful villains of all time. And, to make this issue even more special, Bart was able to witness the resurrection of one of his best friends, Superboy.

Best Writer: Geoff Johns

This is the fifth award for Johns on this blog, passing Mark Waid for most all time. And, as is often the case with Johns, he basically won this award by default. He wrote almost every comic Bart appeared in, from Legion of 3 Worlds to Flash: Rebirth to Blackest Night. That was all Johns, and no one else came close to matching that significance for this character. Of course, I'll always be frustrated with Johns demanding that Bart is only a valid character as Kid Flash. And Johns' artificial boosting of Barry Allen to make him by far the most important Flash ever. But ... I do need to give Johns credit for bringing Bart back in the first place. If it weren't for him, it's likely Bart could have stayed dead for a long time.

Best Artist: George Pérez

How can I not give this award to the man who drew Bart's glorious return? Pérez is a living legend, and it was honor for him to be the artist for this incredibly significant moment in Bart's history. Yes, Pérez did take his time on Legion of 3 Worlds, but the end result was well worth the wait. He crafted a beautiful, amazing story involving hundreds of characters. Each page was a loving tribute to the history of the Legion and comics as a whole. And that's probably the biggest thing that sets him apart from Ethan Van Sciver. I felt so much joy from Pérez's art, but from Van Sciver, I only felt anger.

Best Supporting Character: Brainiac 5

Brainy nabs this award for the second straight year, solely because he was the one who brought Bart back to life. And that's a feat that cannot be topped. Yes, Bart did have some fun with Superboy and XS this year, but nobody can match the contribution of Brainiac 5. But it wasn't just that he brought Bart back, it was the how and the why that testified to his true genius. Upon learning of the vision of Superboy-Prime defeating the Legion, Brainy immediately began working to combat this threat from every possible angle, including psychological. And that's where Bart came in. Brainy had to do quite a bit of planning and behind-the-scenes work to pull it off, and it all came together perfectly. A wonderful hero was brought back to life and a horrible villain was defeated.

Best Villain: Superboy-Prime

And that horrible villain, Prime, earns this award for the second time. Eobard Thawne is causing trouble in Flash: Rebirth, and Black Hand is making a mess of things in Blackest Night, but neither of those had the emotional connection to Bart like Prime does. I mean, just think about it: Bart was literally brought back to life just to battle Superboy-Prime. You can't get any more significant than that. And I've always been a fan of the special place Bart has in Prime's heart. He is legitimately terrified of Bart. When Prime heard Bart's coming back, he completely freaked out and immediately dropped everything he was doing to try to prevent this. Luckily, Superboy-Prime was too late.

Next time, we'll begin the year 2010, which will feature lots of Blackest Night, Bart's official return to the Teen Titans and a couple more appearances on Smallville. But everything starts with our return to The Flash: Rebirth #5.

Blackest Night #4

Geoff Johns Writer
Ivan Reis Penciller
Oclair Albert & Joe Prado Inkers
Alex Sinclair Colorist
Nick J. Napolitano Letterer
Adam Schlagman Assoc. Editor
Eddie Berganza Editor
Cover: Reis • Albert • Sinclair
Alt. Cover: Rodolfo Migliari

Our main cover features some of the villains who have been revived, giving an unusual amount of focus to Copperhead. I admit he is rather intimidating looking, but he really doesn't play a big part in this story. In fact, he really only shows up in the background of some big group shots. I also have to complain about the design for the revived Maxwell Lord. For some reason, DC decided he needs a length of rope around his neck, even though he was quite famously killed by Wonder Woman with her bare hands. There was no rope around his neck when he died, so why does he have one now? And this isn't just on the cover — Lord has that rope on all the inside pages of every Blackest Night issue he appears in.

The black-and-white cover surprised me with the amount of flat pencil shading shading Reis did. You actually have to concentrate really hard to tell what's what on this cover, making me appreciate the inking of Albert and coloring of Sinclair much more. Of course, the true horror element comes through even more when you take away the inking and coloring. When you see the final cover, you say, "Oh, that's Copperhead. He's not a big deal." But when you strip it down to just the pencils, you're treated to an almost abstract image of claws, teeth and fangs.

Our alternate cover shows the revived original Atom, Al Pratt, attempting to devour the second Atom, Ray Palmer. This is a striking, realistic image that could pass as a movie poster. And it features a fairly important moment of this story.

Our story begins with Black Hand roaming the Coast City cemetery, muttering about the Blackest Night's eventual triumph over light, while the Black Lantern rings report power levels above 93 percent and continuing to climb. Meanwhile, Barry Allen, Mera and the Atom are battling a handful of zombie Black Lanterns at the headquarters of the Justice League of America in Washington, D.C. The handful of zombies quickly grows into a small army of revived villains, including Doctor Light, and some fallen heroes, including Firestorm. Sadly, half of Firestorm is still alive, but he's only able to take control of his body long enough to warn the living heroes to evacuate Earth.

The zombie Aquaman also shows up, and Barry prevents Mera from interacting with him by pushing all the zombies away with a whirlwind. The Atom then dials 911 on a phone and pulls Barry and Mera with him through the phone line and into the 911 call center.

In Gotham City, the Scarecrow finds himself envious of all the fear people are feeling at the sight of these zombies. The zombie Azrael approaches Scarecrow directly, but he says he's used his fear toxin too many times, and now nothing frightens him anymore. Since he's not feeling any strong emotions, the zombie Azrael can't hurt him and just walks away, killing more innocent bystanders to bring the Black Lantern power levels past 95 percent.

In Metropolis, Lex Luthor acknowledges that he has killed quite a few people over the years. And now that the dead are rising, he wisely sees that he would be a prime target for his many victims. So he secludes himself deep within his laboratory, behind many levels of security.

Back in the 911 call center, Barry takes charge, telling the phone operators to tell the public to stay indoors and to keep calm — the Justice League is on this. Since the Green Lanterns have gone off world in search of the source of the Black Lanterns' power, Barry says it's up to the rest of Earth's heroes to "hold the fort" until the Green Lanterns return. He tells Ray and Mera to find the original Green Lantern, Alan Scott, to see if his powers can stop the zombies and if he or anyone else could possibly help poor Firestorm.

Mera and Ray are both feeling a lot of doubt in themselves, saying this is a job for Superman and Wonder Woman. Barry says the two of them know more about this threat than anyone else right now, so they're going to have to act in place of Superman and Wonder Woman. Barry relates to Mera's feelings of being an outsider, and he boosts Ray's confidence by pointing out that even though he ran away to the subatomic universe, he did choose to come back because he's a hero. So Barry sends them on their mission, while he goes off to play "Paul Revere" and rally the rest of the heroes around the country. Once Barry takes off, Mera asks Ray, if they're supposed to be Superman and Wonder Woman, then who's Barry supposed to be. And in a moment of pure Geoff Johns fanboy, Ray answers simply, "The Flash."

Ray calls Mr. Terrific and drags Mera through the phone line in one of Mr. Terrific's T-spheres. They emerge in Manhattan, where the JSA are battling a handful of zombies. Meanwhile, Barry begins visiting a bunch of heroes including Wonder Woman, Green Arrow and Kid Flash (as we saw in Blackest Night: Titans #3). Barry tells them all that black rings have descended on Earth, raising their family and friends from the dead. He clarifies that these zombies are not the real people brought back, and that they're not entirely unstoppable. He tells them of the Green Lanterns' plan, saying it's up to them to protect Earth until then. Barry warns everyone to keep their emotions in check, as the Black Lanterns are attracted to strong outbursts of positive or negative emotion. He also theorizes that the Black Lanterns can be weakened by attacks of light.

Unfortunately, Barry didn't stick around long enough for Bart to tell him what the Titans have learned about Dove. But Bart (and Wally) do ask Barry where they should go. Unfortunately, Barry is only able to vaguely tell them to go "wherever there's trouble." Meanwhile, Black Hand is still muttering about the destruction of light in the Coast City cemetery, talking to a skull in his hand — presumably the skull of Bruce Wayne. As he reaches a sinister-looking door marked with the Black Lantern symbol, the Black Lantern power levels pass 97 percent.

The Atom has finally got in touch with Alan Scott, who regretfully explains that his Green Lantern ring is nothing like the Green Lantern Corps rings, connected to a power source on Oa. Alan is able to push the zombies back, but he can't actually destroy them. Bart's old friend Damage begins to despair at this, so Ray hops on Grant's shoulder and encourages him to shed his fear. Through his little pep talk, we learn that Grant is the son of the original Atom, Al Pratt, who just so happens to be here as a zombie Black Lantern.

Fearing the effect Al will have on Grant, Ray shrinks down inside Al and regrows to normal size, grotesquely tearing the zombie apart from the inside out. Ray encourages Grant to join him in beating down the zombies over and over again until it's over for the sake of the world. At this display of courage, Grant's rage, fear and love are replaced with a single emotion — hope. Unfortunately, this makes Damage a prime target for the Black Lanterns, and his heart is ripped out by none other than Jean Loring, Ray's ex-wife. And Damage's heart is the lucky one that puts the Black Lantern power levels at 100 percent.

Somehow, someway, Barry is able to sense this monumental moment, and he's drawn to Coast City. Black Hand has used the fully charged Black Lantern to transport it and the captive Guardians from Space Sector 666 to the Coast City cemetery. Once it's in place, Black Hand commands Nekron to rise, followed by the rest of Coast City. Barry helplessly watches as thousands of rings dive into the graves of the cemetery, raising an entire army of the dead, lead by Nekron, a man with a chain around his neck and a very large scythe in his hand. Nekron quickly spots Barry and says, "Barry Allen. You owe me your life. You all do."




This is still a pretty good story. The most haunting aspect here was the death of Damage. Because he and Atom were punished for doing everything right. In so many stories, a younger hero is angry and scared, but a mentor gives an inspiring speech, which fills the young one with enough confidence to go off and save the day. But in this story, feeling too much hope is a bad thing and a fatal weakness. Kind of horrific, mind-blowing stuff.

Blackest Night is ostensibly a Green Lantern story, but Johns wisely kept the Green Lanterns away for this entire issue, forcing a rather random grouping of heroes to deal with this threat. Well, Mera and Atom were random, but Barry Allen wasn't. Johns could have used virtually anybody to fill that role, but I feel like he chose Barry to show him off and almost justify bringing him back. The Flash: Rebirth still isn't done, but Johns has already put Barry front and center in a massive DC-wide event, elevating him to almost mythical proportions in terms of inspiration and leadership. It's a little frustrating, seeing as how Wally or almost anybody else could just as easily fill this role. It's also a bit strange, considering how Barry's personality here is so much different from the angry, whiny Barry we've seen in Rebirth so far. But I guess that last problem is entirely Ethan Van Sciver's fault for missing his deadlines.

Well, that's it for comics with a publication date of 2009. Next time, we'll do our Year in Review, before finally returning to Flash: Rebirth.

Blackest Night: Titans #3

"When Doves Cry"

Writer: JT Krul
Art: Ed Benes
Color: Hi-Fi Design
Letter: Rob Clark Jr.
Cover: Ed Benes, Rob Hunter & Rod Reis
Variant Cover: George Pérez
Asst. Editor: Rex Ogle
Assoc. Editor: Adam Schlagman
Editors: Brian Cunningham & Eddie Berganza

Our main cover shows a frightened, beat-up Dove surrounded by a handful of Black Lantern zombies. It's not a particularly original pose, but it is effective. And as we'll see inside, this confrontation is the key of the whole miniseries.

I got this image of the variant cover from dc.fandom.com. It is fitting that George Pérez was brought in to draw the zombie versions of so many of the characters that he and Marv Wolfman either created or popularized. Of course, Phantasm doesn't actually appear in this issue, but who's counting?

Our story begins with Donna Troy continuing to wrestle with the happy memories of her family against the horrific sight of her deceased husband and son attacking her as zombies. Donna (still in her pajamas) is still buried in the Titans Tower with Wonder Girl and Kid Flash. And although our heroes have been cautious to not move too much to worsen the cave-in, the zombie Terry and baby Robby have shown no such caution and are fast approaching.

Donna tells Bart to get her costume so she can fight the zombies. Cassie tells Donna she shouldn't fight because she's injured, but Donna insists that this is one battle she has to fight.

Outside, Beast Boy finally frees Cyborg and Starfire from Omen's illusions by turning into a stegosaurus and smacking both Omen and Terra. Beast Boy quickly alerts his friends to the new Black Lantern zombies, and they immediately begin battling Pantha, Wildebeest, Tempest, Aquagirl and Dolphin. But Beast Boy still has a hard time fighting Terra, who tries once again to remove his heart, seeing the fear and love in it.

Suddenly, Donna punches her zombie husband up out of the ground. Bart and Cassie emerge right behind her, with Bart noting the death of Garth and worrying who else has been killed by the Black Lanterns. Donna finally manages to put aside all her conflicting memories and the manipulative words of the zombies and run her fist through Terry's chest before grabbing baby Robby and tearfully snapping his neck.

Perhaps inspired by this, Beast Boy launches an all-out attack on Terra, hitting her as a cheetah, lion and bear. He says he realizes this zombie isn't the real Terra, but he also finally admits that deep down, he always knew the real Terra was a traitor. Seeing Gar's heart consumed by rage, the zombie Terra mockingly says he's still in love with her. Beast Boy says he knows, as he rips Terra in half.

The zombie Garth attacks Bart with a shower of ice shards, saying this should remind him of the icy chill of being beaten to death by the Rogues. Garth also notes that Bart should have stayed dead, but "he" wanted Bart back. And then Dove comes out of nowhere to attack Garth (don't ask me how she went from San Francisco to Washington, D.C., and back so quickly).

Omen haunts Cassie with images of Robin and Superboy fighting for her love, but Donna quickly saves her by snapping Omen's neck. But to Donna's horror, the zombies Terry and Robby have quickly reformed. Dove is also heartbroken by this sight, and collapses to her knees in despair, saying the zombies can't be stopped. The zombie Holly attacks Dove, and tries to remove her heart. But the Black Lantern can't identify the white emotion in Dove. And as Holly touches Dove, the zombie begins shrieking in pain. The Black Lantern ring says "connection severed," and soon all that's left of Holly is a smoking pile of dust.

All the other zombies suddenly stop fighting our heroes and immediately head toward Dove, identifying her as their only true threat. Dove quickly begins to figure out what's going on, and she advises the Titans to stay away. As the zombies close in on her, she manages to emit a large blast of white energy, which disintegrates all the zombie except for Terra, Hawk and Garth. Exhausted by this, Dove momentarily falls unconscious, where she sees a vision of the original Dove, Don. He urges her to not give up on the original Hawk, Hank.

When Dove wakes up, she sees the three remaining zombies have fled, and no one really has the heart to chase after them just yet. Donna asks Dove what she did, and Dove isn't quite able to explain it, other than she knows those zombies, including Holly, are now gone. Donna says they should go stop those three runaways, but Bart suddenly receives a super-speed message from his grandpa Barry Allen. He tells the others that, according to Barry, dead heroes are rising all over the world.

While Bart relays the rest of Barry's message to Donna and Cassie, Cyborg pulls Beast Boy aside, urging him to not let these head games get to him. Gar admits he chose to look past Terra's treachery and believe she was a good person deep down because he loved her. Vic says it's a good thing to hope for the best in people, but Gar just chose the wrong girl. Gar confidently says the right girl for him is still out there, and he'll find her eventually.

Donna gathers everyone together, saying they need to get Dove to the front lines of this war. She also tells Dove to stay close to her, saying she can feel the Black Lantern power spreading in her, and she needs Dove to kill her if she becomes one of them. As Donna looks at her teammates, one of her eyes becomes a Black Lantern eye, enabling her to see their emotions. Dove is pure white, but everybody else is a mix of colors. Beast Boy, rage, hope and will; Starfire, rage and love; Cyborg, will and rage; Wonder Girl, hope, rage and fear; Kid Flash, hope and fear.




This was a pretty good miniseries. Ed Benes is a solid artist (even if he's obsessed with scantily clad, overly sexualized women). And J.T. Krul has a good handle on these characters. Of course, this story focuses mainly on Donna Troy, Terra and Hawk and Dove — characters I care very little about — I did like the little bit of Bart we got here. He and Cassie, the youngest of this group, are understandably still full of fear after all of this. But Bart's quick conversation with his grandpa has given him a great amount of hope to balance out that fear. And that brings me to the best thing about this miniseries — it lines up perfectly with the main Blackest Night series. And it made its publication deadlines (a rarity at DC in this era).

Let's check out the new ads:

Red-hot adventure. Subzero rescue. Artemis Fowl: The Arctic Incident – The Graphic Novel.

The Soul. A new way to roll. KIA.

Naruto Shippuden available for the first time on DVD. This was a fantastic series that unfortunately suffered from a prolonged, meandering ending.

Tekken 6. This is your fight. For Xbox 360 and PlayStation.

The dark knight. The man of bronze. Batman/Doc Savage Special.

The Authority and WildCats. Can they save their harsh new world?

The DC Nation page is by Simona, talking about Catwoman.

What mattered the most was remembered the least. Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days for Nintendo DS. I'm slowly making my way through these games. They don't make a lick of sense, but they are kind of fun.

Next time, we'll see exactly what Barry told Bart in Blackest Night #4.

DC Universe Halloween Special '09 #1

Kid Flash in Mirror Games

Written by Joe Harris
Art by Andrei Bressan
Color by Marcelo Maiolo
Letters by Rob Clark Jr.
Editors: Adam Schlagman & Eddie Berganza

Our cover by Gene Ha shows Bizarro reading the previous year's Halloween Special to a group of hostages, while Superman, Guy Gardner, Robin and Kid Flash rush in to save the day. It's a fun, goofy cover, showing us that even though this is Halloween, most of the 13 stories inside will be a bit on the lighter side. And frankly, that's the way to go in the middle of this massive horror event, Blackest Night. For me, personally, it's nice to see that Bart is back and was chosen as one of the few characters on this DC-wide event.

Our story begins in a dark bathroom with a group of teenage girls trying to summon Bloody Mary through the mirror. To their horror, the mirror shatters on its own and out of it emerges Mirror Master, who promptly grabs the youngest girl and holds a large mirror shard against her throat. One of the girls is able to slip away and call the police, and soon a police barricade is set up around the house and a hostage negotiator is summoned.

This naturally attracts the attention of a couple of trick-or-treaters, who are dressed as zombie versions of Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman. They had apparently heard ahead of time of the girls' desire to summon Bloody Mary, and they begin to argue whether she is real. Kid Flash eavesdrops on the conversation, before quickly zipping away. The kids didn't see Bart, but they did hear a strange sound like somebody kicked out the plug of an Xbox 360, or shot it with a death ray. As Bart rushes off to what he's sure is a battle with Mirror Master, he kicks himself for spending Halloween night listening to police bandwidth instead of finding a party to go to.

Inside, Mirror Master still has a tight hold on the youngest girl, while making all the other girls gather up ever mirror in the house and smash them to bits. Mirror Master hears Kid Flash approaching, but Bart smartly vibrates through the wall behind him and punches the Rogue, causing him to let go of the girl. Bart hits Mirror Master a couple more times, before asking him what's with the hostages and the large pile of mirrors at his feet.

Mirror Master explains that he wants to destroy all the mirrors because he saw something much worse than him zipping through the Mirror Dimension. He doesn't know if it's just because it's Halloween or what, but he's sure this monster will rip them all up if she gets out. Bart asks who Mirror Master's talking about, and the youngest girl says, "Bloody Mary."

At those words, the shards of mirrors begin to swirl in the air and the image of a ghostly woman appears. Kid Flash gets all the girls safely to the back corner of the room, and then — somehow, someway — he causes Bloody Mary to disappear as quickly as she appeared. The art is extremely confusing here, and all we get for an explanation in the dialogue is a "targeted hypersonic wave."

Bart pulls himself out of the girls' embrace, saying he should probably check on the neighbors, and the girls invite him to their party. Bart then notices Mirror Master somehow slipped out in the confusion, and is unable to find Evan McCullough later. But we, the reader, see that Mirror Master escaped the old fashioned way — just running down the road. He's choosing to avoid using any mirrors for now to avoid Bloody Mary, but he happens to step on a puddle of water as he says her name aloud for some reason. Bloody Mary promptly pops up out of the water and drags Mirror Master down with her.




This story sucked. I know it's just a Halloween feature that's not supposed to be taken too seriously, but it still felt like only a half-formed idea. Joe Harris wanted to do Bloody Mary and Mirror Master, but apparently didn't spend any time figuring out what Bloody Mary is, how she works and how to get rid of her. Kid Flash was only thrown in here for the cliché "teenage boy saves teenage girls" scenario. This was a weak story with incoherent art. And that's a shame, because I'm craving a fun Kid Flash story.

Next time, there won't be a whole lot of fun, as we wrap up the Blackest Night: Titans miniseries.

Blackest Night: Titans #2

Bite the Hand that Feeds

Written by: J.T. Krul
Pencils: Ed Benes
Inks: Scott Williams (pages 1-6) & Ed Benes
Colors: Hi-Fi Design
Letters: Rob Clark Jr.
Cover by: Benes, Hunter, & Pete Pantazis
Variant Cover by: Brian Haberlin
Assoc. Editor: Adam Schlagman
Asst. Editor: Rex Ogle
Editors: Eddie Berganza & Brian Cunningham

Our cover shows Donna Troy holding her deceased son, who looks like a normal, healthy toddler in her eyes, but in the reflection of the mirror is revealed to be one of the Black Lantern zombies. This is a pretty fun and creepy image, even if it's not 100 percent accurate with the story inside. One interesting thing to note, though, is the baby's teeth. Last issue, Donna was lamenting that Robert died just after growing his second tooth. But now that he's been revived by this unholy evil, he has a mouth full of teeth.

I got this image of the variant cover from mycomicshop.com. It shows the original, zombified Hawk attacking the new Hawk. For some reason, this comes off as rather silly to me. I guess the Zombie Hawk's face looks more goofy than scary.

Our story picks up in Titans Tower, with Donna examining the strange baby carriage that suddenly appeared in her room. But the carriage is empty, except for a rattle with the Black Lantern symbol on it. Suddenly, Donna's deceased husband, Terry, approaches her, holding baby Robert in his arms, casually talking about how the boy wants his mommy. Unlike Beast Boy's initial encounter with Terra, there is no psychic manipulation going on, and Donna clearly sees her family members as decaying zombies. But she's too surprised and confused to react in a rational way. Believing this must be a dream, Donna automatically takes Robert into her arms. The baby immediately sinks his teeth into Donna's neck, as Terry explains this isn't a dream, but a nightmare.

Outside, Starfire and Cyborg are battling Zombie Omen, who has created a bunch of illusions of herself, while Zombie Terra has trapped Beast Boy with some rocks. Terra wants to pull out Gar's heart, but only when it's overwhelmed by a single emotion. Right now, Gar is feeling love, fear, rage and hope, which is thwarting Terra's attempts for the moment. Beast Boy turns into a marten to slip out of the rocks, then a hawk to fly above Terra and land on her as a mastodon. Gar still tries to talk to Terra, but she only repeats her desire to take his heart.

Terra's hand begins to glow black, which sends a lot of pain through Gar's body. But Starfire saves Beast Boy in time, hitting Terra with the full blast of her star bolts, completely incinerating the zombie. Kory apologizes to Gar, explaining that the creature she just blasted wasn't really Terra, and Gar actually tells Kory she did the right thing. They both then turn to help Cyborg, who is caught in a psychic trance by Omen.

In Georgetown University, Washington, D.C., Dove can only stand helplessly by as the Zombie Hawk removes Hawk's heart from her chest. Consuming the rage within that heart brings the Black Lantern power levels up to 57.03 percent. The Zombie Hawk then turns on Dove, but is unable to recognize any emotions in her. As Dove battles Hawk, a black ring flies onto Holly Granger's finger, commanding her to rise. So now Dove has two zombie Hawks to fight.

Back in the tower, Donna is pushing away her zombie son that was trying to kill her. With tears in her eyes, she begs her family to stop, saying she doesn't want to hurt them. Luckily for her, Bart and Cassie were still in the tower and hadn't gone to bed yet, and they just happened to hear Donna's screams. Bart rushes in and pulls Donna out into the hall, telling Cassie that she was being attacked by something straight out of the "I Am Legend" movie. As Bart and Cassie examine the black, festering wound on Donna's neck, the zombies see the fear in Bart, the will in Cassie and the hope in Donna.

Outside, we see that Omen has put Cyborg in a paradisiacal psychic state, where he's fully human and relaxing in the bright sun. Omen does a similar thing to Starfire, sending her back to her wedding with Dick Grayson. The Zombie Terra, meanwhile, repairs herself, quickly regaining the form she had when she began this attack. Terra opens up the earth beneath the tower and begins pulling it down. Our heroes inside the building feel like an earthquake is hitting them, but Bart says he didn't feel any early vibrations, meaning the epicenter of the quake must be directly underneath them.

Unfortunately, Bart was apparently too surprised and confused by this to get Cassie and Donna out before they become buried in the Earth. Cassie asks him to find a path out, but Bart worries about using his powers in such an unstable environment, saying he'd be like Gar in a china shop. If, you know, Gar was a bull. Donna tries to explain to Cassie and Bart what happened, struggling to convince herself that her zombie family members aren't actually her family. But as she talks, the spreading black infection on her neck and face causes her to collapse in pain and her eyes to turn into the Black Lantern symbol.

Outside, Beast Boy is trying in vain to free Starfire and Cyborg from Omen's illusions. And as Terra gloats over finally being able to kill the Titans, she's joined by zombie versions of Aqualad, Aquagirl, Dolphin, Pantha and Wildebeest. Garth's appearance is especially troubling, as he was alive and well when this whole Blackest Night thing began.




I really don't have much to say about this issue. The horror story is continuing, but I don't have a particularly strong emotional connection to most of these characters. And there really didn't seem like there's any reason for Bart to be here. And frankly, I am kind of mixed on the bit of Bart we did get here. On one hand, I do like using Bart to show us how scary all this is. Zombie babies are downright creepy. But on the other hand, I feel like Krul just does not have a great handle on Bart as a character. Being able to feel approaching earthquakes is an odd ability that I've never seen brought up before. And in the time it took Bart to explain that, he could have — and should have — pulled Cassie and Donna out of the building. It was an odd moment.

Well, let's check out the new ads:

got milk? with Chris Paul of the New Orleans Hornets. In the 2008-09 NBA season, Paul was an All-Star, First-Team All-Defense, Second-Team All-NBA, and led the league in assists and steals.

Will the betrayal of one, mean the end for them all? Bleach: The Movie 2.

Prepare for an all-out brawl. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Smash-Up for Wii and PlayStation 2.

2009 Design Scholarship Challenge, announcing winner Shane McCallion.

A world divided. A journey uncharted. Aion for PC DVD-ROM.

Justice League of America. A new era begins with James Robinson and Mark Bagley.

Final Crisis: Legion of 3 Worlds collected as a hardcover graphic novel.

The dead have risen! ... And no one is safe! Blackest Night. (Gotta love ads for the very thing you're reading.)

On the DC Nation page, Ian Sattler promotes the Superman/Batman: Public Enemies movie.

Next time, in case you haven't got enough horror, we'll check out a special Kid Flash story in DC's Halloween Special '09.

Blackest Night: Titans #1

When Death Comes Knocking

Written by: J.T. Krul
Pencils: Ed Benes
Inks: Rob Hunter, Jon Sibal & JP Mayer
Colors: Hi-Fi Design
Letters: Rob Clark Jr.
Cover by: Benes, Hunter, & Rod Reis
Variant Cover by: Brian Haberlin
Assoc. Editor: Adam Schlagman
Asst. Editor: Rex Ogle
Editors: Eddie Berganza & Brian Cunningham

Our main cover shows Beast Boy grotesquely making out with his deceased girlfriend, Terra. It's disturbing. It's creepy. It's perfect for this story. It's the kind of horrific cover that you can't bear to look at, but you also can't pull away from.

I took this image of the variant cover from dc.fandom.com. It's another creepy closeup of Terra, but without the perverse kissing of Beast Boy, it lacks the impact of the main cover. And just to clear things up, this is the original version of Terra — not the Terra that Bart hung out with for a little bit during his brief stay with the New Titans way back when. This Terra betrayed the Teen Titans and then died in a big fight with Deathstroke. But Garfield Logan genuinely loved her and refused to believe she was actually evil, despite all evidence to the contrary.

Blackest Night was a massive event. Not only did it have its own eight-part main series, and nearly every monthly title at DC had one or two issues tie into this event, but there were also a smattering of three-part miniseries like this. For better and worse, this event will dive deep into every major character's death in the DC Universe.

Our story begins on Heroes Day during Blackest Night #1. We see that Deathstroke is mourning the death of his oldest son, Grant, by tracking down and killing members of H.I.V.E., who hired Grant to take down the Titans, which led to Grant's death. Red Star is mourning his wife, Pantha, and their son, Wildebeest, by drinking a bottle of vodka. And Ravager is celebrating Heroes Day by having sex with a random man and kicking him out of the room immediately by threatening him with her sword.

At Titans Tower in San Francisco, Cyborg, Beast Boy, Starfire, Dove, Hawk, Wonder Girl, Kid Flash, Donna Troy and Geo-Force have gathered to commemorate all the fallen Titans. We get a repeat of Bart's conversation with Cassie about him wishing to take down all the statues, and Cassie responds by saying the return of Bart and Conner is a good start for the Titans. She admits she used to think death was the end, but after looking into Conner's eyes, she now believes that anything is possible. Donna points out that she also has cheated death several times, but laments how the "normal" people never come back, mentioning her toddler son, who was killed in a car crash.

Starfire wonders aloud why they have a statue of Terra the traitor, and as expected, Beast Boy protests this. He argues that Terra's mind was poisoned by Deathstroke, just like Ravager's was. Cyborg says Terra wasn't drugged, but Gar refuses to listen to him and walks away. Hawk and Dove are having a similar debate over the original Hawk, who technically died a villain. As they talk, we see a bunch of Black Lantern rings are trying, but failing, to resurrect the original Dove. However, the grave of the original Hawk is empty.

Hawk and Dove return to Washington, D.C., but are quickly led into a trap by the zombie Hawk. Bart is the last to leave the Titans' hall of statues, taking time to gaze at the statue of Omen, whom he saw die in that terrible Graduation Day story. Donna returns to her room to look at photos of her deceased family. Beast Boy takes a long, solitary walk out by the bay, while Starfire and Cyborg creepily watch him on the security monitors. And Cyborg has the gall to place all the blame on Starfire for upsetting Gar.

Suddenly, Beat Boy is approached by Terra. She looks alive and well, and is eager to give him a big hug. She explains that she faked her death all those years ago and chose to stay away from the team because they suspected her as a traitor. The stunned Gar asks why she chose to come back now, and she mentions the return of Conner and Bart. Terra then pulls Gar in for a kiss, while another zombie watches from the bushes, identifying the emotion of love in Gar's heart.

Turns out, it was a good thing Starfire and Cyborg were spying on their friend, as they were able to see what was happening and swoop in quickly before anything too bad happened. The zombie hiding in the bushes was Omen, who was using her psychic powers to make Gar see Terra as healthy and alive, instead of the rotting corpse we saw on both covers. But even when the zombie Omen is attacked and her mirage fades, Gar is still hesitant to pull away from the zombie Terra, who is now saying she's here to collect Gar's heart.

Donna is awoken from her sleep by the sudden appearance of a baby carriage in her room and the voice of her dead son calling out to her. And after a lengthy battle with Hawk and Dove, the zombie Hawk manages to thrust his hand into Hawk's chest to pull out her heart.




This was a pretty interesting comic. I don't have a very strong connection to all these characters, beyond the tenuous relationship they had to Bart. But I do like the idea of people being attacked by the zombies of people they care deeply about on the very day they were thinking most about those people. As for Bart, he still doesn't have too much to do in this story, beyond feeling a little survivor's guilt and wondering about the nature of death and rebirth. While we ponder on those metaphysical questions, let's check out the new ads:

The battle begins! Smallville Season 8 on Blu-Ray and DVD.

Batgirl. A new ongoing series by Bryan Q. Miller and Lee Garbett.

Magog. Exploding from the pages of Justice Society of America. A new monthly series by Keith Giffen and Howard Porter.

The Brave and the Bold by J. Michael Straczynski and Jesus Saiz.

The DC Nation page shows a blond man lounging on a beach chair under an umbrella, on top of a massive pile of skulls and bones. The caption reads, "On vacation! Be back soon!" I don't know who the blond man is supposed to be.

Next issue ... Black Lantern Hawks!

Adventure Comics #1

Superboy: The Boy of Steel Part One

Geoff Johns Writer
Francis Manapul Artist
Brian Buccellato Colorist
Steve Wands Letterer
Francis Manapul and Brian Buccellato Covers
Sean Ryan Associate Editor
Elisabeth V. Gehrlein Editor

Unlike our favorite speedster, Bart, Superboy was granted the honor of having his own solo series when he was resurrected. Well, sort of. Adventure Comics was historically the home of Superboy and the Legion of Super-Heroes, and that's essentially what we have here once again. So while this is ostensibly a solo Superboy title, he is sharing space with the Legion, usually as a backup story. That's why DC put a faint number 504 behind the large number 1 on the main cover. Although DC wanted the notoriety of a new first issue, they also wanted to indicate a sort of continuation of the original series that last 503 issues. Personally, I would have preferred keeping the legacy numbering and calling this Adventure Comics #504. But that's just me.

Our main cover features the beautiful art of Manapul and Buccellato. Superboy is stoically flying right between his two "fathers." Superman, looking up into the light, and Lex Luthor, gazing down into the darkness, holding a large piece of kryptonite. It's a fantastic cover, although I would have tweaked Superboy's face a little bit. But I'm a huge sucker for Manapul's style, so I still love this all the same.

I got this image of the variant cover from dc.fandom.com (formerly dc.wikia.com — same site, different name). This cover shows a bunch of different images from future storylines in this series, which is an interesting approach. I'm not sure I like it, but I do give them kudos for trying something different. Also note that this cover made the number 504 bold in front of a faint number 1. I kind of feel like DC is trying to have its cake and eat it, too, with this "double numbering," but the uniqueness of the whole situation is intriguing to me. I won't say fully it's good or bad, just ... different.

This issue recaps the first week of Superboy reclaiming his old life. He's living with Ma Kent now, still on the old Smallville farm, with faithful Krypto now a constant presence. Conner is so happy to be alive, he eagerly completes all the daily chores — plowing the fields, taking out the trash, doing the dishes, etc. On Monday, he re-enrolls at Smallville High. On Tuesday, he reunites with the Teen Titans, choosing to destroy the large golden statue of himself in front of the San Francisco tower.

Bart Allen also wants to destroy his own statue, asking Conner to melt it with heat vision, before changing his mind and requesting him to freeze and then shatter the monument. Conner sadly reports he doesn't have freeze breath, so Bart hypothesizes that he just needs to visualize something cold, like the bathroom floor in the tower in the morning (which is why Bart wears his boots to bed, he says). And that's all the Bart we get in this issue. The main takeaway from this story is that even though Conner is thrilled to be alive again, he is secretly worried about becoming like Lex Luthor again. But we're not too concerned about that or the backup of Starman recounting the history of the Legion of Super-Heroes.




Obviously this story takes place before Blackest Night and after Flash: Rebirth. But we're mostly following the publication order on this blog, so we get to re-experience this frustrating era of DC. No wonder they'd try to blow everything up in just two years. Anyway, Bart's back, but we still don't know anything beyond that. He's been seen hanging out with the Teen Titans, but he still hasn't officially shown up in the pages of Teen Titans. And we have no idea where Bart's living now. Max Mercury is back ... right? So has Bart returned to Max and Helen and everyone in Manchester, Alabama, or is he with Jay and Joan Garrick in Denver, or perhaps Keystone? How much of his old life does he remember? Is he now essentially an adult trapped in the body of a teenager? Bart really needed his own solo series to answer these questions, because we sadly know that Geoff Johns isn't going to take the time to answer them in his stories about Barry Allen.

As for this issue, in particular, it was a nice, calm, relaxing change of pace from the frantic pace of Flash: Rebirth and Blackest Night. The highlight of this issue was the artwork, utilizing large panels to let the work breathe and show off the beautiful coloring of sunsets, swamps and schools. I did think it a bit odd that Superboy visited the Teen Titans on a Tuesday, when Johns had previously emphasized the fact of that group being strictly a weekend venture. But I did like Bart and Conner's desire to destroy the monuments of their death to signal their return to the world. Now let's check out the new ads:

got milk? with Danica Patrick.

Get 10% off the strategy guide when you buy it with Batman: Arkham Asylum from GameStop.

DewTour Summer 2009.

Blackest Night action figures.

Batman and Robin by Frank Quitely and Grant Morrison.

The world's strangest super heroes are back ... and they brought those robot guys with 'em! Doom Patrol.

Heroes reimagined by comics superstar J. Michael Straczynski. The Red Circle.

The DC Nation page is Ian Sattler advertising Batman: The Widening Gyre.

Heck: Where the Bad Kids Go by Dale E. Basye.

No safe haven. Only asylum. Batman: Arkham Asylum for PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360. This game changed the video game world, inspiring tons of sequels, prequels and even a Spider-Man game almost 10 years later. I'm not a gamer by any means, but even I played this one.

Next time, we'll get an expanded look at those two panels of Bart from Blackest Night in Blackest Night: Titans #1.

Blackest Night #1

Blackest Night

Geoff Johns Writer
Ivan Reis Penciller
Oclair Albert Inker
Alex Sinclair Colorist
Nick J. Napolitano Letterer
Adam Schlagman Assoc. Editor
Eddie Berganza Editor
Cover: Reis, Albert, Sinclair
Alt. Cover: Ethan Van Sciver & Hi-Fi

Our main cover is a haunting image of a bunch of Black Lantern rings flying out from a skull. This is a more symbolic cover, representing the main idea of this story as a whole. It's dark and creepy and completely appropriate for this event.

Our alternate cover is an ugly, disappointing mess. Did Van Sciver just rush through this one, or what? Because every character on here looks terrible. The main idea is fine. Black Hand lords over our core group of heroes, while a bunch of zombified heroes lurk behind him. You could argue that the zombies should look a bit off, seeing as how they're reanimated corpses, but the living, breathing heroes should follow the basic rules of anatomy. Look at Wonder Woman's back. Look at Superman's arms. This is just amateurish. And why is Black Hand holding a green lantern instead of a black lantern?

My digital copy also includes this black-and-white version of the main cover. Oddly, it almost seems like a mistake. Like someone made a cheap photocopy of the original. I guess it just goes to show you that when the main cover is essentially black-and-white itself, then there's no reason in publishing a separate black-and-white version.

Our story begins with Black Hand traveling to Gotham City to dig up the unmarked grave of Bruce Wayne. Contrary to the Green Lantern #43, Bruce is not buried under a large tombstone bearing his name, but rather in secret next to the graves of Thomas and Martha Wayne. Black Hand removes Bruce's skull and grotesquely licks it. Meanwhile, in Space Sector 666, a black lantern on a lonely rock on a gray world begins producing hundreds of Black Lantern rings that start flying toward Earth.

The next day is a major holiday in America. It was originally a day of mourning to mark Superman's death, but now has turned into a sort of memorial day for all fallen superheroes. The four Green Lanterns do a flyby over a parade in Coast City. Conner joins Clark Kent and Martha in visiting Jonathan Kent's grave in Smallville. The new Firestorm visits the old Firestorm's grave in Pittsburgh. Many of the Teen Titans have gathered at their private memorial beneath their San Francisco Tower. Cassie tells Bart they took down his statue, but he still complains that it didn't even look like him. Mostly, though, Bart wishes they could take down all the statues of fallen Titans.

Bart's half-brother, Owen, (who he probably doesn't know about) is with the Rogues at their hidden graveyard, Avernus, honoring Captain Boomerang with a keg of beer. A smattering of heroes stop by Ted Kord's grave in Chicago, but most of the rest are at Valhalla Cemetery in Metropolis. Mera is at Aquaman's grave in Amnesty Bay, but Garth is begging her to let him move Aquaman's remains to an underwater tomb next to the other kings of Atlantis. And in Gotham City, Alfred Pennyworth prepares to place a bouquet on Bruce's grave, when he discovers that he made a terrible mistake by not having any kind of security in place over this grave.

Barry Allen meets up with Hal Jordan at the headquarters of the Justice League of America in Washington, D.C. Barry is surprised to see there is an entire morgue of deceased super villains hidden under the headquarters, and Hal explains they decided to do this after Dick Grayson uncovered a body snatching operation harvesting superhuman parts. So now just about every major villain lies in this vault, except for the deceased Rogues in their hidden cemetery. Barry vows to find that cemetery and asks Hal to tell him who died while he was in the Speed Force.

In St. Roch, Hawkman receives a phone call from the Atom, who wants Carter to join him in visiting the grave of his wife, Jean Loring. But Hawkman refuses to pay respects to the woman who killed Sue Dibny and started the Identity Crisis. Hawkgirl tries to change Hawkman's mind, but she's unable to.

On Oa, the Guardians of the Universe are uttering one of their favorite phrases: "We have failed." They see a growing shadow emerging from Sector 666, fulfilling the prophecy of the Blackest Night. They resolve to call all the Green Lanterns back to Oa, but the one Guardian who turned Black Hand into the first Black Lantern prevents this distress call by attacking his fellow Guardians. He savagely rips out the heart of one of them, but complains that the heart is worthless since the Guardians abandoned emotion long ago.

Back on Earth, Alfred tells Flash and Green Lantern that Bruce's grave has been defiled, so they quickly head to Gotham to investigate. Meanwhile, the Black Lantern rings begin seeking out deceased heroes and villains, resurrecting them as zombies, just as we saw with Black Hand. As Barry and Hal examine Bruce's grave, the zombie Martian Manhunter approaches them, saying both of them should still be dead.

Hawkman and Hawkgirl are still having an emotional, heart-to-heart conversation. They're so wrapped up in it, that they don't notice the zombies sneaking up toward them in their museum. The zombies can see the love in Kendra's heart and the rage in Carter's heart. Suddenly, the zombies of Ralph and Sue Dibny strike, killing both Hawkman and Hawkgirl. The zombies remove the heroes' hearts, which are consumed by the Black Lantern rings, which report that power levels are now at 0.02 percent. Black Hand arrives to overlook this carnage, proclaiming that the Hawks won't escape death this time. And two more Black Lantern rings fly down, commanding Carter and Kendra to rise.




This is a strong start to a classic horror story. Not only are the dead coming back to life, but they're actively killing people and converting them to their side. This is a bit gruesome, as Johns likes to get from time to time, but I can appreciate a bit of gruesomeness every now and then. I might get sick and tired of it before this event ends, but so far, it's pretty interesting. Reis is a strong artist who can easily handle this enormous cast of characters and convey the horror element of this story.

Bart only had two panels, but they were nice. His wish to take down all the statues is a nice bit of foreshadowing to this story. Are you sure you really want them all to come back, Bart? Be careful what you wish for!

Next time, we'll move into the publication month of October 2009. Ideally, that would have included the fifth installment of Flash: Rebirth, but a certain artist missed his deadline. So instead we have Adventure Comics #1, which also ideally should have come out before Blackest Night began, but hey, we're in the era of DC not bothering to print their stories in order.

Green Lantern #43

Blackest Night Prologue: Tale of the Black Lantern

Writer: Geoff Johns
Pencils: Doug Mahnke
Inks: Christian Alamy
Color: Randy Mayor
Cover: Mahnke, Alamy and Alex Sinclair
Variant Cover: Eddy Barrows and Nei Ruffino
Letters: Rob Leigh
Assoc. Editor: Adam Schlagman
Editor: Eddie Berganza

Our cover shows the focus of this issue (and much of the Blackest Night event), Black Hand, showing off a shiny new power ring over the grave of Bruce Wayne. It's a striking reminder of the most shocking "death" from Final Crisis and the ominous arrival of a villain with power over death.

Our variant cover shows Black Hand battling Hal Jordan. Despite the rain and the blood pouring from Hal's mouth and nose, this cover lacks the drama of the main one. Everything just looks fake and plasticy. And the teeth are incredibly distracting. Barrows tried to draw every single tooth in both characters' mouths, but he drew all the teeth identically. Just a mouth full of incisors without any canines or molars.

In an ideal world, Johns' Legion of 3 Worlds story would have finished before his Flash: Rebirth story started. And in that ideal world, Flash: Rebirth would have wrapped up before Johns' Blackest Night epic began. But we're not in an ideal world, so we have to try to make best with a bit of overlap (I can only imagine how difficult it was for readers at the time). Unlike the past two stories, though, Blackest Night is a DC-wide event, and a massive one, at that. It is ostensibly a Green Lantern story, but it spread to nearly every other title DC was publishing at the time, as well as carrying its own dedicated miniseries. It's very easy to get sucked deep into this tale and the enormous Green Lantern universe Johns created, but this is a Bart Allen blog, so we're going to skim across the top.

This issue sets up the main villain of Blackest Night — essentially Death itself. At least, as far as we can tell so far. One of the Guardians of the Universe has split away from the others on Oa and has become obsessed with/corrupted by Death. This Guardian then works with Death to create the first Black Lantern — William Hand, better known as the Green Lantern villain, Black Hand.

Hand was the son of two morticians and always obsessed with death, even as young boy. As he grew older, he began hearing Death speak to him. And after surviving a near-death experience with some aliens, Hand begins receiving visions of all the major DC characters who have died and been brought back to life. Naturally, this includes our recently resurrected speedster, Bart Allen.

Death tells Hand he feels cheated by all these people, and he wants them back. So Hand agrees to become Death's herald. He kills his family, then himself. The Guardian arrives on the scene and vomits up a black ring that flies onto Hand's finger and tells him to rise. Hand's injuries heal and the "Zombie" Black Hand rises up and vows to extinguish the light with his new power.




This is actually a nice setup for a comic book event. Lots of people like to complain about how nobody stays dead in comics, so what would happen if Death itself decided to take that personally and start going after all the people who had cheated death? Unfortunately, I know how long this event is going to drag out, and I'm already dreading it. But that's nothing to hold against this issue.

I also want to note that this is the first issue I've reviewed that I don't actually own. I got these images through the DC Universe app, which has completely blown me away with the amount of digital comics they're making available. Old, new, obscure and popular. If you want it, you can probably find it there. It's not just a streaming service for Young Justice. And no, DC is not paying me to advertise this — I just genuinely am a huge fan of it.

Next time, we'll begin the story proper with Blackest Night #1.

The Flash: Rebirth #4

Flash Facts

Geoff Johns Writer
Ethan Van Sciver Artist
Rob Leigh Letterer
Brian Miller of Hi-Fi Colorist
Ethan Van Sciver Cover
Brian Miller Cover Color
Chris Conroy Assistant Editor
Joey Cavalieri Editor

Our main cover is another fun display of multiple levels of storytelling. Against a backdrop of the Reverse-Flash's colors, we have Barry being struck by lightning and splashed by chemicals. But inside the bolt of red lightning, Barry is in his Flash outfit. This is some of Van Sciver's better work.

Our variant cover is not quite as good. In place of innovation and creativity, we have stiffness and laziness. Eobard Thawne is standing menacingly behind the shattered bones of Johnny Quick, surrounded by copious amounts of red lightning. The skull of Max Mercury behind him is rather misleading, as we'll see inside. Anyway, these two covers neatly show the contrast of Van Sciver's work. When he wants to, he can be creative and brilliant. But all too often, he lets himself slide to the easy, cheap tactic of giving us a bland mess of stiff, over-muscled figures.

Our story picks up with Eobard confronting Barry and Max in the Speed Force. Eobard is mad that Barry has arrived early, saying he thought Barry wouldn't retreat into the Speed Force until he killed Wally, Jay or Bart. Barry is surprised to see that Eobard is alive, and he explains that he has his own resurrection coming up, thanks to a friend of Barry's.

Barry lashes out at Eobard for killing Johnny, but he's unable to land a blow. Eobard explains that his negative Speed Force is taking over Barry's positive Speed Force. Max likens it to a cancer, and Eobard praises him for attempting to study the Speed Force, unlike Barry. Eobard elaborates, saying he generates the Negative energy with each step he runs, and it's his lightning that is poisoning the speedsters through Barry. He says when he was resurrected (in the future), he was disappointed to learn that Barry had already sacrificed himself to stop the Anti-Monitor. So he began studying for a way to bring Barry back to exact his revenge.

When Bart was struggling to take Superboy-Prime to the Speed Force by himself, Barry "opened the door" to help pull Prime in. And Eobard noticed that Barry "left the door open." So he sent Barry a subliminal message to lure him out of the Speed Force during Final Crisis. Eobard then transformed himself into a new kind of speedster by recreating Barry's initial accident (which we saw at the beginning of this story). Eobard's efforts granted him the ability to generate negative energy, which he used to contaminate Barry and turn him into the Black Flash. But now that Barry has thwarted Eobard's plan by burning off that corrupting lightning, Eobard has decided to go kill Barry's family himself.

We return to Fallville, Iowa, where Superman, Green Lantern and Wonder Woman have returned to tell the rest what happened. Iris doesn't believe that Barry would just give up like that, but Wally understands that Barry didn't want to risk anyone else's life. However, Wally says he won't accept Barry's decision. He tells everyone to rebuild the lightning rod, while he goes into the Speed Force to bring Barry back. Jay warns him that he'll die like Savitar if he touches Barry, but Wally's encouraged by Superman's report that Barry shed the black aura. Still, Jay is worried that Wally will become lost in the Speed Force, too. Bart reminds him how Max never got out, but Wally vows to bring him and Johnny back. Insisting that he'll use Linda as his lightning rod to find his way home again, Wally takes off.

At the West family home, Irey has put on her superhero outfit in an attempt to follow Bart, who she thinks is real cool. Linda warns her daughter that it's too dangerous, but Irey says she can help them with her powers. Jai coldly says that Irey can only walk through stuff, which he bets Bart thinks is stupid. This puts Irey into a crying fit and she runs downstairs — right into the Reverse-Flash.

As Wally runs into the Speed Force, he also sees flashbacks of his life pass by him in reverse — the birth of his twins, meeting Bart for the first time, etc. Barry, meanwhile, is trying to fight through Eobard's corrupting lightning, telling Max they need to find a way out. But Max says he can't leave. Jay has Joan, Wally has Linda, Barry has Iris, but Max says he doesn't have an emotional lightning rod to ground him. Max says Johnny lost Libby, so he also couldn't escape the Speed Force. And speaking of Johnny, his daughter has once again collapsed in the JSA headquarters, constantly repeating the speed formula.

Barry tells Max that he can't run anymore since he's lost his connection to the Speed Force, but Max says Barry's powers work more like Thawne's. Max explains that all those times he tried to run into the Speed Force but only ended up jumping forward in time was because he was actually running toward Barry. He says when Barry was struck by lightning, he didn't tap into the Speed Force, he created it. And when Barry runs, he generates the kinetic wall between the present and the time barrier, creating an electrical field that exists in every dimension, universe and era. Max warns that if Barry doesn't stop Thawne, his Negative Speed Force will grow and continue to eat away at Barry's Positive Speed Force, killing all the other speedsters. Max begins to weaken under the strain of Thawne's energy, and he begs Barry to run, to generate more fuel, and to save Bart and the others.

At the West home, Linda leads Jai downstairs to apologize to his sister, but to her horror, the Reverse-Flash is down there holding onto Irey. Thawne quickly grabs Jai, saying he can feel the twins' tie to the Speed Force tangled in a knot. He begins to send some energy through the two children, saying he'll "untangle" their knots before strangling them. Linda calls out to Wally (through her ring?) and tells him Thawne is there. Somehow, Jay and Bart hear her distress call and immediately push Thawne out of the house and down the street, causing a sonic boom that shatters all the nearby windows.

As Barry tries to run, and Wally keeps searching for him, Jay and Bart interrupt the planned Flash parade with their battle with Thawne. Jay realizes that Eobard was behind all this, and Thawne boasts that he's hurt Barry in more ways than he could ever imagine. Thawne then begins pushing Jay forward at a high speed and somehow manages to take away Jay's aura that protects him from friction, which causes the elder speedster to burst into flame. Bart quickly puts out the fire on Jay, telling Thawne to leave him alone. Eobard turns on Bart, saying that even though his mother is a Thawne, his father is an Allen, which pollutes his blood. Bart jokes that on the bright side, he's only half-related to Eobard.

In the Speed Force, Barry finally manages to generate some positive energy and starts moving forward, just as he hears Wally calling out to him. Barry tells Max to come with him, but Max says he can't. So now it's Barry's turn to give Max a pep talk, reminding him of all the good he did by raising Bart. Barry says Max is family and he still has a lot of race to run. So Max takes Barry's hand, and together they reach out and find Wally. And in a blast of lightning, the three speedsters suddenly appear right in front of Thawne, preventing him from killing Bart.

Jesse finally stops repeating the Speed Formula, saying she now knows the secret of the Speed Force. And Barry leads Wally, Jay, Max and Bart into battle against Professor Zoom.




At long last, Max Mercury has returned! I know I should be more excited by this, but a couple of things are dampening my enthusiasm. One is Van Sciver's artwork, another is the fact that I know Max won't do very much in his return before being wiped from existence in the New 52. But mostly, I'm distracted by the confusing nature of the Speed Force. Actually, if you just read this story by itself, things do make enough sense. The problem arises when you begin to ponder the incident of Bart bringing Superboy-Prime to the Speed Force, and Wally taking his family to the Speed Force, and how Bart was sent back, but suddenly aged for some reason, but Superboy-Prime didn't, and how Wally and his family came back, and, and, and ... you get the point.

Geoff Johns raised a lot of questions about the nature of the Speed Force and never took the time to answer them. Instead, he opted to ignore everything that's ever been written about the Speed Force and make it all about Barry. It's not enough to make him the best Flash or the fastest Flash. He had to make Barry the source of all Flashes, the literal generator of the Speed Force. This doesn't just give Barry an overinflated sense of importance, but it has a diminishing, detrimental effect on all the other Flashes. Of course, Wally and the others have already been shoved aside to make room for Barry, but this whole Speed Force thing is essentially the nail in the coffin.

Next time, we'll start another massive Geoff Johns story that started before his last one finished. I'm talking about Blackest Night, which begins with a prologue in Green Lantern #43.

Final Crisis: Legion of 3 Worlds #5

Book Five

Geoff Johns – Writer
George Pérez – Pencils
Scott Koblish – Inker
Hi-Fi – Colorist
Nick Napolitano – Letters
Adam Schlagman – Assoc. Editor
Eddie Berganza – Editor
Cover: George Pérez & Nei Ruffino
Sliver Cover: George Pérez & Ruffino

Our main cover features Dawnstar, which I find to be an unusual choice for the finale of this miniseries. Not to discount Dawnstar, but I don't consider her to be as essential to the Legion as Cosmic Boy, Lightning Lad, Saturn Girl and Brainiac 5. Regardless, it is a very pretty cover.

Confession time: This whole series I thought this was called the "Silver Cover," which never made any sense. Today I finally realized it's the "Sliver Cover," which makes a whole lot more sense. I could go back and fix my mistake on the past reviews, but I'll leave them up as a monument to my stupidity. Anyway, this sliver cover puts the spotlight on Superboy, recently revived from the dead. I'm glad Kon's getting some love, but this image is a bit underwhelming. I'd like something brighter, something happier.

Our story begins at the end of time, where the Time Trapper is still attacking Superman, Cosmic Boy, Lightning Lad and Saturn Girl. Meanwhile, in the 31st Century, Time Trapper's younger self, Superboy-Prime, is trying to kill Conner with a big chunk of ice. Conner makes fun of Prime for his weak attempt at a "death blow," which makes Prime start stuttering about how he was going to do something way cooler. Conner says he doesn't know how or why he's here, but he does remember dying in Wonder Girl's arms. So Conner now wants revenge against the one who forced Cassie to watch her boyfriend die.

Conner worries that Prime had hurt Cassie, but Prime cowardly confesses he didn't. He quickly catches himself, though, and tries to threaten that he will fly back in time to punch Cassie in the face, lamely adding that a punch to her ugly face would be an improvement. As Prime takes way too long to explain his stupid joke, Sodam Yat hits him from behind with the full force of the Green Lantern Corps. Bart and Jenni are right behind him, and Bart can't help but ask Conner how sweet this reunion is. Conner asks if Bart wants to say their old battle cry, and Bart admits he's been dying to. And as they hit Prime again, Bart shouts, "Titans together!"

Prime angrily starts to fly away, complaining that Conner isn't Superboy, but Super Annoying. Demanding to know who found the clone, Prime eventually spots Dawnstar and blames her for using her tracking powers to bring everyone here (he's not entirely wrong). Dawnstar's boyfriend, Wildfire, flies in front of Prime, absorbing the full blow of his attack, creating a large explosion. As Dawnstar and Wildfire's counterpart from another world repair his containment suit, Conner quickly begins punching Prime again. This time, Prime promises to actually go back in time and break Cassie, just like he broke Conner.

Conner says he wants to rip that smirk off Prime's face, but he realizes Prime isn't worth hating, and he even admits he feels sorry for Prime. But Conner does insist that Prime stop wearing the "S" and he uses his heat vision to blast a line across Prime's "S" scar. Prime cries that his logo has been ruined, but this has far more important repercussions in the future. At the end of time, Time Trapper's scar suddenly gains the Conner-inflicted mark. Saturn Girl manages to contact the Adult Brainiac 5, asking him what this means. Adult Brainy hypothesizes that Time Trapper may have seen one potential future where the Legion lost today, but he must have seen a dozen others where the Legion won, and he can't possibly differentiate between them all. In fact, Adult Brainy, theorizes, the Time Trapper has probably always merely been a sentient alternate timeline rebelling against theirs, as his own history and even his identity changes as the true timeline marches on. Adult Brainiac 5 then formulates a plan and asks Saturn Girl to weaken Time Trapper as much as they can.

So Saturn Girl, Lightning Lad and Cosmic Boy combine their powers to send out one massive distress call to the end of time. If there were any Legionnaires who were absent in this story so far, they're here now, as dozens of heroes answer the call. Everybody who has ever been a Legionnaire, honorary or otherwise, is here now. Even Supergirl and the Super Pets. Meanwhile, the White Witch finally defeats Mordru by absorbing all his magic powers, but this causes her to become the Black Witch. Bouncing Boy and Triplicate Girl/Duo Damsel make an appearance, but now she can make an unlimited number of copies of herself, and is calling herself Duplicate Damsel.

Finally, the Time Trapper is knocked unconscious, so Adult Brainiac 5 has Gates open a portal to bring him back to the 31st Century. Just as the Time Trapper wakes up, he finds himself face-to-face with his younger self. Prime doesn't believe that Trapper is himself, saying he'll never get old and wrinkly and grow a beard. Trapper tells Prime to shut up and listen to him, since he's smarter, but Prime refuses to take orders from this "grandpa." As they argue, Adult Brainiac 5 advises everyone to keep their distance.

Trapper is shocked to see how stupid his younger self is, and Prime prepares to punch Trapper's dentures through the back of his skull. Trapper tries to warn Prime to stay away, but Prime doesn't listen. As he punches his older self, he creates a weird, blue, reality-alternating blast. Everyone can only stand by horrified (except for the Other Brainiac 5, who calls him an idiot), as the Time Trapper and Superboy-Prime fade away from existence. Prime calls out for help, but no one can do anything. Soon, all that's left is the Time Trapper's ragged purple cloak.

Now that the battle is finally over, Superman gets a chance to embrace Conner, who jokes about having a stiff neck after being in that chrysalis for a thousand years. Clark says Ma Kent is going to be thrilled, and Conner looks at Bart, saying a lot of people will be. Bart, meanwhile, is trying to convince Jenni to come back to the past with him, saying he feels something different, which he thinks means Max Mercury is back. (Sadly, because of publication delays, we know Bart was feeling the return of his grandfather, Barry Allen, and not Max.)

Some Legionnaires are understandably worried that they broke their most important code and killed Superboy-Prime. But the Brainiacs explain that when Time Trapper interfaced with himself, he altered the history of him becoming the Time Trapper in the first place and ceased to exist. Adult Brainy describes this event as "hitting a giant cosmic reset button," which he believes caused enough trauma to Prime's body to leave him powerless. And for now, he's essentially under "house arrest."

We see that Superboy-Prime has awoken on Earth-Prime. Once again, he's entirely naked except for a thin rag conveniently keeping him modest. And to his astonishment, Prime came to right in front of his house. He gleefully runs back in to see his parents and girlfriend, whom he thought died a long time ago. But his girlfriend, Lori, runs away from Prime in terror, fleeing out the back door. Prime's dad darkly shows his son that they've been reading this very comic series, including the Sinestro Corps War and Infinite Crisis. Prime's family knows exactly what he's done, and they are both disgusted and horrified by him.

Back in the 31st Century, all the heroes stick around for a week to clean up the damage their battle caused and rebuild the prison planet. They hold a memorial for all the heroes killed in the fight, and Sodam Yat begins sending the Green Lantern rings across the universe to find new members of the Corps. And the Brainiacs set to work on sending everyone home. Superman asks the Adult Brainy how Prime was sent back to his Earth if it was destroyed in Crisis on Infinite Earths, and Adult Brainy explains that Earth-Prime was reborn during Infinite Crisis. He says this became obvious when the Element Lad of the "Other Legion" was able to make kryptonite that affected Prime. The "Other Legion" is from Earth-Prime. "Our Legion" (the Legion we've interacted with the most on this blog) is from Earth-247, which was not reborn during Infinite Crisis.

So the Legion of Earth-Prime prepares to head back home, given strict instructions to keep an eye on Superboy-Prime. And the Legion of Earth-247 decides to venture out into the Multiverse to look for other people like themselves who are stranded without a world. Bart again asks Jenni to come with him to see Wally and their grandma Iris, but Jenni decides to stay behind. Even though her parents (and Bart's) left this world because of the Reverse-Flash, Jenni wants to look for any remaining relatives here.

With everyone's fate decided, the three Brainiacs build two Cosmic Treadmills attached to large platforms for each Legion (although the Brainiacs do have to have one last argument about who deserves the most credit for this). With Jenni powering one treadmill and Bart powering the other, everyone cries out, "Long live the Legion!" as they disappear in a flash of light. Now that everything is finally back to normal, Adult Brainiac 5 takes off for a long overdo haircut.

In the present day, in the Teen Titans Tower in San Francisco, we see Nightwing, Raven, Robin, Supergirl, Wonder Girl, Donna Troy, Roy Harper, Beast Boy, Starfire, Cyborg and Wally West. Apparently Superman had asked them all to meet there, but didn't tell them why. Before too long, Superman makes his dramatic entrance, presenting the revived Conner and Bart. Wally says, "Ohmygod." Conner casually greets the stunned faces with, "'Sup?" Bart cheerfully adds, "Hi, guys!" Cassie, in disbelief, asks Conner if he's really back, and with a massive grin, he says, "Isn't it cool?" Conner and Cassie quickly embrace, and Wally is the first to hug Bart.

We then leave that happy scene to return to Earth-Prime. Unfortunately, Prime has decided to use his parents' fear of him to bully them into acting as his personal servants — ironing his Superman T-shirts and preparing him grilled cheese sandwiches. But no tomato soup, since he hates vegetables. Prime also ominously hints at some horrible fate that befell Lori. Prime spends his time reading comics in the basement, and complaining about how stupid they are. As he reaches the end of this issue, he turns and yells at the reader, saying he was supposed to be the real Superboy and that he's not going away. He then logs on to the internet to continue his war against stories he hates. But while he types out his trolling comments of disgust, his eyes begin to glow red, indicating that his powers have returned.




What a phenomenal series. And I'm not even a huge Legion fan! But it was incredible seeing all these characters come together for one massive battle. Everyone's here, and everyone has something to do. And even though we had to wait quite a while for Pérez to finish his work, at the end of the day, the story is so much stronger to have the same penciller and the same inker on each and every page. This is truly one of the most impressive achievements we've seen on this blog.

It probably isn't the most natural thing to have Bart and Kon be revived in a Legion story, but they both have had their fair share of adventures with the Legionnaires. But more importantly than that, this is the story of Superboy-Prime's defeat, and such a story could not be told without the two heroes he hates and fears the most. Fittingly, Prime was the one who actually defeated himself, but that wouldn't have been possible without the psychological trauma of Kid Flash and Superboy haunting him from beyond the grave.

And what a poetic ending for Prime. He's finally given everything he ever wanted. He gets to go back home and be the world's only superhero. But his past actions have tainted his arrival, and his mind is too warped to progress past the whiny brat that won't eat his vegetables. Despite this opportunity to start with a clean slate, Prime chooses to remain embittered and lash out against the universe that rejected him in his own impotent way. Like so many internet trolls, Prime is unable to understand that change is a constant in the world of comics. And just because things change, that doesn't negate or diminish any of the old stories. And if you don't like the new stuff? So what? Don't be a jerk about it online.

So now Bart is finally, truly back! Granted, he's still Kid Flash, and we'll have to wait another 10 years before he gets to be Impulse again, but we'll still try to have fun with his second run in the yellow suit. For the meantime, let's check out the new ads:

The Soul. A new way to roll. Kia.

Paying for college has never been this much fun. Navy.

MattyCollector.com. Exclusive toys, news and more!

Splat. Rebellious colors. Long lasting, semi permanent hair paint.

The DC Nation page is Dan DiDio talking about how Orange County, Florida, recognized George Pérez for his accomplishments in the field of comics and with the Heroes Initiative charity.

We have a five-page preview of Adventure Comics #1, which we will review in due time, as Kid Flash does make a cameo in it.

Knowing and Push on DVD and Blu-Ray.

Robot Chicken: Star Wars Episode II on DVD.

Next time, we'll return to The Flash: Rebirth #4.